A unique opportunity?

October 29, 2016   ·   1 Comments

THE TALK THESE DAYS is about the need for better infrastructure, and the figures tossed about are in the billions of dollars. But as we see it, some improvements can be made without any huge expense and require little more than some ingenuity.

A classic example is in the area of commuter rail service. Undoubtedly, the great success story in Ontario is the GO (Government of Ontario) train, which next year will celebrate its 50th anniversary.

Launched on May 23, 1967 it began  with single-deck coaches running between Oakville and Pickering plus limited rush-hour service to Hamilton. GO Bus service, which started out in 1970 as an extension of the original Lakeshore train line, has since become a full-fledged network feeding the rail service and serves communities trains do not reach.

Today, the double-decker trains run from as far west as Kitchener and as far north as Barrie, and Orangeville has had GO buses for nearly 20 years.

GO Transit’s success can perhaps best be measured by the fact each of the trains on the Lakeshore, Kitchener, Milton and Barrie lines can deliver roughly 2,000 passengers to downtown Toronto, and with up to three trains per hour in the morning an evening rush periods that means at least 20,000 commuters reach their jobs without needing their cars.

In the circumstances, it would be interesting to see how much the current Toronto-area gridlocks would be if for some reason (such as a strike) the GO trains weren’t available.

But however good the existing service may be, it has one major failing that ought to be corrected as soon as possible. That failing is in the lack of appropriate rail vehicles in off-peak hours.

As we see it, it makes no sense for trains with 10 or more double-deck coaches to be running between the morning and evening rush hours as well as on evenings and weekends when trains similar to the UP (Union-Pearson) Express could handle the volume.

The argument we’d expect is that such smaller trains would cost a lot and not be of much use during peak periods.

But our answer to that is that those same ‘mini’ trains could and should be used to serve communities that currently have either no GO service or just bus service yet do have rail lines. Three examples are Orangeville/Caledon, Alliston/New Tecumseth and Peterborough.

However, of the three, only one offers a crucial opportunity – that of quickly demonstrating the viability of such commuter services. As we see it, that opportunity lies in the existence of a train for such a demonstration.

That train is the Credit Valley Explorer, and the demonstration would be morning and evening runs between Orangeville and Streetsville with stops at Alton, Inglewood and Brampton and connections with trains on GO Transit’s Kitchener and Milton lines.

Obviously, to be viable the demonstration would have to be attractive to commuters who have jobs in Brampton, Mississauga or Toronto. And to be attractive it would have to be competitive in terms of both cost and time.

Since the speed of trains on the Orangeville-owned Orangeville-Brampton Railway is currently limited to 30 miles an hour (50 km/h), some track work would be required to permit the trains to operate as they once did, when CP’s “Dayliners” made the trip from Owen Sound to Toronto in three hours and it took less than 90 minutes between Orangeville and Union Station.

We obviously don’t know, but suspect that a modest investment by GO Transit would bring the rails and roadbed up to a standard that would allow a train out of Orangeville to reach Brampton in an hour and Streetsville in another 20 minutes.

We think the combination of good connections, affordable GO fares and comfortable  coaches would indeed prove attractive.

Isn’t it an idea worth pursuing?

Readers Comments (1)

  1. Robert Wightman says:

    As you say the speed of the line is slow because of poor track. The old running time to Union through Streetsville on the CP was 90 minutes. This would probably be too long for most people and CP probably would not give up any more time slots on their main line from Toronto to Windsor.

    Running the train in on the Kitchener line from Brampton will not happen because the curve, if it could be built, is too sharp.

    The best that you could hope would be a train that dropped people off in Brampton and they would walk to the connection with the Kitchener line.

    The use of two sets of equipment is too expensive to consider. When (if) GO electrifies and converts to what are called electric multiple unit cars then these can be coupled into long trains for rush hour and shortened for off peak service, especially of they are equipped with automatic couplers.

    The existing equipment can be broken in to shorter trains but is very labour and time intensive so it won’t happen though GO is now running some 6 car trains on trips that are lightly loaded in the rush hour and are putting them on the Mt. Pleasant trains in the mid day.


Please note: Comment moderation is enabled and may delay your comment. There is no need to resubmit your comment.