Orangeville Citizen
https://citizen.on.ca/vaccination-approach/
Export date: Mon Feb 6 3:20:34 2023 / +0000 GMT

Vaccination approach


By David Redman

The Government of Canada and the official medical advisory groups are, once again, recommending the immediate need for more doses of both the existing COVID-19 vaccines and the new Omicron tailored vaccines, as the SARS CoV-2 virus continues to evolve, mutate, and spread rapidly.

Emergency managers recognize that a vaccine may be part, but only a part, of the solution for a virus that is spreading through the population. But, until now, vaccines have taken at least three years to be developed and thoroughly tested to ensure they are safe and effective.

Emergency managers also know that a vaccine may not even be possible for a new, evolving, and mutating virus. This is why emergency managers did not count on developing a vaccine until after the COVID-19 virus had become endemic.

In this pandemic, however, we have watched as our Canadian elected officials and Medical Officers of Health focused on a vaccine as the only solution. Not surprisingly, not all countries 1 have followed this approach.

If we return to the first principles in managing emergencies like the COVID-19 pandemic, we can easily see what is wrong with our current approach.

The first step in discussing a response to a situation is to establish that there really is a need, and emergency managers do that by starting with a hazard assessment 2.

Managers realized that, beginning in February 2020, mortality caused by the SARS-CoV-2 virus was mainly in the senior demographic cohort of the Canadian population, particularly those with multiple comorbidities. The virus was no more deadly 3 than the seasonal influenza virus for young people unless they were severely immune compromised.

Consequently, most Canadians did not require a vaccine. All the COVID waves that passed through the population supported this conclusion.

Emergency managers also knew in March 2020 that a safe and effective vaccine was years 4 away from being developed and properly tested. But our elected officials and their supporters persuaded Canadians that a vaccine could be rushed in a few months, ignoring the lesson that safe vaccines take time to develop and test properly.

In addition, this same group of elected officials and their supporters believed the only way out of this pandemic while waiting for a vaccine was by invoking the use of Non-Pharmaceutical Interventions (NPIs), which we now call “lockdowns.” This use of NPIs and the belief that “lockdowns” are effective and vaccines must be used is both wrong and deadly 5.

Rather than relying on vaccinations for the whole population, the focus should have been on treatment for those most at risk.

It soon became evident that SARS-CoV-2 was a fast-evolving virus. Developing an effective vaccine may not be possible for a virus that quickly mutates; the virus that causes the common cold is a good example of such a virus. Developing an effective vaccine is very difficult, if not impossible.

Recent studies of the new Omicron BA 4.6 variant support 6 this conclusion. “By the time that a supposed new winter wave of infections would occur in late November or December, it will likely be BA.4.6, and the new booster will be outdated anyway.” Yet officials say we need to approve the new variant vaccines WITHOUT trials.

The SARS-CoV-2 is, in some sense, similar to the cold virus: it mutates and becomes more contagious but less deadly. This suggests that, over time, severe conditions diminish and vaccines become less necessary.

Natural immunity has increased and, not surprisingly, has now reduced the severity of the illness when reinfected. This is a typical outcome and usually is how a pandemic draws to a close, with the virus becoming endemic 7 and of acceptable risk in our daily lives.

Government officials have told us that taking the vaccine has decreased the number of deaths, but there is no evidence for this claim. As a result, it is not clear whether the vaccines are working effectively or if the virus is becoming less deadly. Yet government officials are not investigating this hypothesis, claiming it is all due to the “effective” vaccine.

It has historically been assumed that effective vaccines will stop people from becoming ill, needing hospitalization and dying. The COVID-19 vaccines did none of these things.

In Israel, in June of 2021, researchers showed that the vaccines lost their effectiveness within a few months. Similar results were reported in the UK in August, which led the UK to stop 8 reporting on the vaccine's effectiveness 9. Weekly government evidence in Canada showed similar results. It is now common knowledge that the COVID vaccines have little effectiveness.

Yet, in Canada, the Canadian Minister of Health is now planning to administer a new vaccine, which will be tailored specifically to the current Omicron variants, providing no useful remedy to a SARS-CoV-2 virus that mutates into a new form 10.

Finally, leading scientists have openly debated 11 the safety 12 of these vaccines. Even if the vaccines are less risky and potentially more beneficial, no cost-benefit analysis of the vaccination protocol has been performed. Unfortunately, Canadians may learn that these vaccines are much less safe than expected.

Other countries have moved on to better ways of dealing with the pandemic. Why is the Canadian government so blind to these alternatives?

David Redman had a distinguished military career before becoming the head of the Alberta Emergency Management Agency in 2004. He led the provincial response to the devastating floods of June 2005 and the team in developing the 2005 Provincial Pandemic Influenza Plan. He retired in 2013.

Links:
  1. https://r20.rs6.net/tn.jsp?f=001_1vkiEY-qO6h6CjHPx NsSJbRBq3PkQyTU1y3wkiaLLNkGsMnqlDzuIJbwhU9_3i0rhoH rtUjhBLMqVzLvjUZPXa8_EjokrJWoaATMIuZPbwy3UqDsFjWCZ c6v4RYwxsoK4RZ7YhoObZuZvCfBcigkIkrbJj8CXbi54LzmFOM Rzfu0bpVO10i6WSEeMRGcA7B3s7BDWO2AztvKu_HvavaFFNb6z NqBmni&c=D-3PlqzfJtdx2TmGYVQ6SzWRoEyuv4-hcf60k qlvF-uTMqYcH0iwgg==&ch=9vd-tplVC5scNqFIi8tYCEs IwBfHf2YcuvZJNZ9GTAs9hRQ2ZlIa2A==
  2. https://r20.rs6.net/tn.jsp?f=001_1vkiEY-qO6h6CjHPx NsSJbRBq3PkQyTU1y3wkiaLLNkGsMnqlDzuIJbwhU9_3i0PDsZ V6V2CHf4-RjWgwCyhoBugm1PWxZ6n8piIKwsIRFv-vwP9-SMCH yQJ1cX8oDpdO2-rPi6gv2wWV50UYxv1N2r4wJSVGopCdaOC254 XaN-80ybBgiUgrby8IzytSGJsyk70NN6zDdc4Oxwxc4DXw==&a mp;c=D-3PlqzfJtdx2TmGYVQ6SzWRoEyuv4-hcf60kqlvF-uTM qYcH0iwgg==&ch=9vd-tplVC5scNqFIi8tYCEsIwBfHf2Y cuvZJNZ9GTAs9hRQ2ZlIa2A==
  3. https://r20.rs6.net/tn.jsp?f=001_1vkiEY-qO6h6CjHPx NsSJbRBq3PkQyTU1y3wkiaLLNkGsMnqlDzuIJbwhU9_3i0mnhY mFVgO7PKXbe1Ewq6GiypcDT6iUgTI9pEPibJ5DD_obVMRpHj3I ZLHuQ7Gt9W6gu72YZQ9YGL8-nvlM0dwM0yHDNx5w2j4y7RwXt4 vU4WjiQmZV0z0yt1JUePpO2I31nMHHiYKUAm48sYwMFR4g==&a mp;c=D-3PlqzfJtdx2TmGYVQ6SzWRoEyuv4-hcf60kqlvF-uTM qYcH0iwgg==&ch=9vd-tplVC5scNqFIi8tYCEsIwBfHf2Y cuvZJNZ9GTAs9hRQ2ZlIa2A==
  4. https://r20.rs6.net/tn.jsp?f=001_1vkiEY-qO6h6CjHPx NsSJbRBq3PkQyTU1y3wkiaLLNkGsMnqlDzuIJbwhU9_3i0tk0s k1jSPOOYVW-4pBZQT9u8gR9gdRf3hMftcohBwCABjKwDsEQrH9 EiRpaMh6P-yf8jkOe5NmDyncSRPOEt_J50OBOnfDPcKyrMqF_P ImS96BFDP1iXPMcOTeXXxefhYneS_wvts3pF2M0GN3_LJ-nLM5 y8Ae1hY6bHSpzugROQMz__0Q4obw==&c=D-3PlqzfJtdx2 TmGYVQ6SzWRoEyuv4-hcf60kqlvF-uTMqYcH0iwgg==&ch =9vd-tplVC5scNqFIi8tYCEsIwBfHf2YcuvZJNZ9GTAs9hRQ2Z lIa2A==
  5. https://r20.rs6.net/tn.jsp?f=001_1vkiEY-qO6h6CjHPx NsSJbRBq3PkQyTU1y3wkiaLLNkGsMnqlDzuIJbwhU9_3i0PDsZ V6V2CHf4-RjWgwCyhoBugm1PWxZ6n8piIKwsIRFv-vwP9-SMCH yQJ1cX8oDpdO2-rPi6gv2wWV50UYxv1N2r4wJSVGopCdaOC254 XaN-80ybBgiUgrby8IzytSGJsyk70NN6zDdc4Oxwxc4DXw==&a mp;c=D-3PlqzfJtdx2TmGYVQ6SzWRoEyuv4-hcf60kqlvF-uTM qYcH0iwgg==&ch=9vd-tplVC5scNqFIi8tYCEsIwBfHf2Y cuvZJNZ9GTAs9hRQ2ZlIa2A==
  6. https://r20.rs6.net/tn.jsp?f=001_1vkiEY-qO6h6CjHPx NsSJbRBq3PkQyTU1y3wkiaLLNkGsMnqlDzuIJbwhU9_3i0mjZs 24d1T5YEUNxqRmmksw9L5mFA6j7eaLaFjqXwGkzv6VInRI07A4 Ou4xVL0gs5QSCrYZaBU4fOie1ymOu7Z52ehqV6hhgjG1LomVG7 PctttTLP7l7AChfmAoYKLuImRxkQj1BbH42u2fGyn4p7tUzuAC nTXwCw15jXhbY9VoMj8tUJ6JgHDTpSki_MVg8WWLQSk5Az5WpG 6CopWXru7Q==&c=D-3PlqzfJtdx2TmGYVQ6SzWRoEyuv4- hcf60kqlvF-uTMqYcH0iwgg==&ch=9vd-tplVC5scNqFIi 8tYCEsIwBfHf2YcuvZJNZ9GTAs9hRQ2ZlIa2A==
  7. https://r20.rs6.net/tn.jsp?f=001_1vkiEY-qO6h6CjHPx NsSJbRBq3PkQyTU1y3wkiaLLNkGsMnqlDzuIJbwhU9_3i01Pvf HYc2O-zPUA42fllRWDKfKEgPU7a2Is67qsYG1yoJTTbSN0VegC eO-2w28AYNCM1iKfNymOglYzvqmAefR1ggcR-dGho9h62gZiv2 69isKqvLNXTIoFyUeUqVotf17HMgqJjFzymOTNZa0gOWotDfGu NOjTnmA1wz3oJeN8zaBzZr5l8q7elJYJF2J9-BonaW2WZ1aN6Q AE6SWFjKqNwM3vOrFWQk&c=D-3PlqzfJtdx2TmGYVQ6SzW RoEyuv4-hcf60kqlvF-uTMqYcH0iwgg==&ch=9vd-tplVC 5scNqFIi8tYCEsIwBfHf2YcuvZJNZ9GTAs9hRQ2ZlIa2A==
  8. https://r20.rs6.net/tn.jsp?f=001_1vkiEY-qO6h6CjHPx NsSJbRBq3PkQyTU1y3wkiaLLNkGsMnqlDzuIJbwhU9_3i0ZzGG kIbITNMhQMylVHZ6S_j-upvilqzcyOTGqioZ8X-Xws3lhYYew_ EaBIgI-afdyjwdJQIWMDyrVqmv-ix0RpDzevhxvwEHINH8HCD_ _RKIV9uY1IOhbirytGkRwUro8dVhtbZp40u8croyLBFx2rkvNp NTnAH0&c=D-3PlqzfJtdx2TmGYVQ6SzWRoEyuv4-hcf60k qlvF-uTMqYcH0iwgg==&ch=9vd-tplVC5scNqFIi8tYCEs IwBfHf2YcuvZJNZ9GTAs9hRQ2ZlIa2A==
  9. https://r20.rs6.net/tn.jsp?f=001_1vkiEY-qO6h6CjHPx NsSJbRBq3PkQyTU1y3wkiaLLNkGsMnqlDzuIJbwhU9_3i0Y6lM tgkvgK-8tQlcj0-5CyAjIUV-WqJ3SvI9q-MXP4YZYV0mbNZivm aOpjz7U2qgjqMuSVYgiA8_YTX3Xokz0T5BzScBFUK9PH9SMAMj IXRM1FEMKyGutsxGoooe2ElJPUzmoymWKTs=&c=D-3Plqz fJtdx2TmGYVQ6SzWRoEyuv4-hcf60kqlvF-uTMqYcH0iwgg==& amp;ch=9vd-tplVC5scNqFIi8tYCEsIwBfHf2YcuvZJNZ9GTAs 9hRQ2ZlIa2A==
  10. https://r20.rs6.net/tn.jsp?f=001_1vkiEY-qO6h6CjHPx NsSJbRBq3PkQyTU1y3wkiaLLNkGsMnqlDzuIJbwhU9_3i0mjZs 24d1T5YEUNxqRmmksw9L5mFA6j7eaLaFjqXwGkzv6VInRI07A4 Ou4xVL0gs5QSCrYZaBU4fOie1ymOu7Z52ehqV6hhgjG1LomVG7 PctttTLP7l7AChfmAoYKLuImRxkQj1BbH42u2fGyn4p7tUzuAC nTXwCw15jXhbY9VoMj8tUJ6JgHDTpSki_MVg8WWLQSk5Az5WpG 6CopWXru7Q==&c=D-3PlqzfJtdx2TmGYVQ6SzWRoEyuv4- hcf60kqlvF-uTMqYcH0iwgg==&ch=9vd-tplVC5scNqFIi 8tYCEsIwBfHf2YcuvZJNZ9GTAs9hRQ2ZlIa2A==
  11. https://r20.rs6.net/tn.jsp?f=001_1vkiEY-qO6h6CjHPx NsSJbRBq3PkQyTU1y3wkiaLLNkGsMnqlDzuIJbwhU9_3i0ktmT sjiaWpjko3EfMfCs5gKBuPrZ7wMTSdhofOThNY0_5PbZ24IyMk CWH4CZdOWGoa1AVtAVcKScqjck3vISwGgkDRCcoxWzNb8zB6lz CFbN6a4CVW-vgw==&c=D-3PlqzfJtdx2TmGYVQ6SzWRoEy uv4-hcf60kqlvF-uTMqYcH0iwgg==&ch=9vd-tplVC5scN qFIi8tYCEsIwBfHf2YcuvZJNZ9GTAs9hRQ2ZlIa2A==
  12. https://r20.rs6.net/tn.jsp?f=001_1vkiEY-qO6h6CjHPx NsSJbRBq3PkQyTU1y3wkiaLLNkGsMnqlDzuIJbwhU9_3i0TuwZ leqU3lsbnpajbPxsAFwf0HY6R9bUdhZyGZ9imBhST2-2YJ6dcY Wp-2mxOU4symOzbny8PqwU4dAnfrdG51rNe2etEfv65QEMqhLt ZpfAR1WDDYQf0dp1pqOn8VTyvkWt9sTaNqzlI0Aye63cFTuRvv rjWWYSR-jvI-cIL3WfpkHjNWr9mGy5akTbBcslosoXuVaKOFjp WRK1iV3x6g==&c=D-3PlqzfJtdx2TmGYVQ6SzWRoEyuv4- hcf60kqlvF-uTMqYcH0iwgg==&ch=9vd-tplVC5scNqFIi 8tYCEsIwBfHf2YcuvZJNZ9GTAs9hRQ2ZlIa2A==
Post date: 2022-09-29 16:32:33
Post date GMT: 2022-09-29 20:32:33

Post modified date: 2022-10-06 15:43:31
Post modified date GMT: 2022-10-06 19:43:31

Export date: Mon Feb 6 3:20:34 2023 / +0000 GMT
This page was exported from Orangeville Citizen [ https://citizen.on.ca ]
Export of Post and Page has been powered by [ Universal Post Manager ] plugin from www.ProfProjects.com